J.C. Ventimiglia/Sun photo WICCANS pass a cauldron used during a healing ritual. Sophia Anila, Olathe, holds the cauldron while observed, clockwise, by Cassandra Carpenter, Kansas City-North; Jason and Mari Alflen, Liberty, Mo., and a Gardner resident who says she is known as Walidah.


Join our Mailing List!

Please click the link below to sign up for your community paper mailing list. Stay up to date with all the events going on in your community as well as the latest news.

Sign Up Today!






Old(er)-Time Religion

BY: Sheri Baker-Rickman, Staff Writer

Wednesday, March 21, 2007 4:50 PM CDT
printable version  e-mail this story   View Comments on this Story
After a rocket-propelled grenade struck Army Sgt. Patrick Dana Stewart's helicopter Sept. 25, 2005, in Afghanistan, his widow, Roberta, faced religious prejudice.

Roberta applied to have the symbol of her husband's faith placed on his grave marker in Nevada, but the Department of Veterans Affairs refused. The VA does not recognize Stewart's religion, Wicca, often called witchcraft.

Grave marker symbols for atheists, humanists, Muslims, Hindus, Serbian Orthodox, United Moravian, Eckankar, United Church of Religious Science and various Christian faiths are allowed by the VA. But the pentagram n a five-pointed star inside a circle representing Pagans n is not one of 38 VA-approved symbols of belief.

Stewart received a pentagram Dec. 2 on his grave marker, found on the Wall of Heroes at Northern Nevada Veterans Memorial Cemetery in Fernley. He received the marker because the cemetery is state-owned and Nevada Gov. Kenny Guinn intervened on Stewart's behalf.

The VA continues to deny relatives of other veterans a pentagram. They receive grave markers with no faith symbol.

Cheryl Locke, a Pagan for 20 years, blamed President George W. Bush for Pagans being denied military grave markers.

“The current administration has issues,” Locke, Kansas City, Mo., said.

A comment by Bush during the 2000 election fuels Locke's belief.

“I do not think witchcraft is a religion and I do not think it is in any way appropriate for the U.S. military to promote it,” Bush said.

Executive Pastor Jeremiah Johnston of First Family Church in Overland Park agreed with Bush that Wicca should not be recognized.

“We live in an age where almost every cult wants to hijack the word 'church' and parlay themselves into an acceptable religion,” Johnston said. “The history of the pentacle has been connected with occultic ramifications. Obviously, some who embrace Paganism disassociate from that reference. The position of First Family Church is that religion apart from Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior is devoid.”

Despite disagreement from some churches and Bush, the Army recognizes Wicca. The Army's handbook for chaplains explains the faith's practices.

“I helped revise the section on Wicca in the Army chaplain handbook,” the Rev. Selena Fox, who officiated at Stewart's memorial ceremony, said. “The Department of Defense will allow soldiers to have the pentacle on their dog tags and Wicca ceremonies on military installations, that's no problem. But the VA won't allow people to have the symbol of their faith on a grave marker.”

Fox is a Wiccan priestess and founder of Circle Sanctuary, an international nonprofit organization and church providing information and networking for Pagans.

“I have seen firsthand how this denial has caused tremendous stress,” Fox said. “To lose a husband, son or daughter, you have to deal with the loss, but to also face a lack of religious freedom … that complicates the grief.”

Circle Sanctuary is one litigant in the fight to add the pentagram to the list of military grave markers.

“After repeated attempts to get the VA to correct this long-standing inequity, we have taken this to federal courts,” Fox said.

Regarding the symbol, the VA issued a statement to The Sun that approval of new symbols has been deferred until new rules are published.

Since the fight for the pentagram began, the VA has approved several grave symbols, including for the Christian and Missionary Alliance; the United Church of Christ; the Humanist “Emblem of Spirit”; the Presbyterian Church; the Izumo Taishakyo Mission of Hawaii; the Soka Gakkai; and the Sikh.

“Approval of the Sikh symbol was expedited because a Sikh soldier died,” Fox said. “There are Pagan Iraq War veterans, some from the Korean War, and a number of others waiting for a symbol on their headstone.”

Americans United for Separation of Church and State represents Circle Sanctuary; Karen DePolito, whose husband, Korean War veteran Jerome Birnbaum, died last year; and Isis Invicta Military Mission.

“Americans United filed this lawsuit because we believe the Department of Veterans Affairs is engaging in religious discrimination by refusing to recognize the Wiccan pentagram,” Americans United Executive Director Barry W. Lynn said. “The families of Wiccan soldiers who die in service to their country deserve to have their religion recognized alongside other faiths. It's a simple matter of justice, decency and fair play.”

Jenny Singer, born Jewish but now a Pagan living in Florida, said people of her faith face discrimination often. In a custody battle in Clay County, Mo., Singer said her ex-husband tried to use Wicca to label her an unfit parent.

“(My children's) father and their stepmother have done everything in their power to make my children believe that my religious beliefs are wrong,” Singer said. “I never imagined that I would have to take the witness stand in a courtroom to defend my right to religious freedom. That experience changed everything I thought I knew about the Constitution and the rights I had previously taken for granted.”

Singer said losing custody of her children happened because of her faith, though the judge stated Wicca is not harmful.

Sophia Anila, Olathe, a Wiccan for six years, said ignorance causes prejudice against the faith.

“So many, unfortunately, don't know about Wicca and assume we are devil worshippers,” Anila said. “It is something they don't know so they are scared and they don't want to see it in public.”

Anila, who leads the Wise Women Society, said Christians are afraid to see the pentagram inscribed permanently on anything, especially a grave marker.

Previously a fundamentalist Christian for 24 years, Anila decided to study religions and that led to Wicca.

“Do some research on your own,” she said. “Education prevents ignorance.”

Anila said recognition of the pentagram should happen but may take time.

“Change for the U.S. government isn't easy,” she said. “If people start to work up a great amount of attention to this issue, something that is broken can be fixed. This is broken and it needs to be fixed.”

Comments on "Old(er)-Time Religion"

Comments are limited to 200 words or less.

Mandy wrote on Apr 13, 2007 12:40 PM:

" Shame on Pastor Jeremiah Johnston for saying that any religion that does not acknowledge Jesus as Lord and Savior is devoid. Just because he doesn't think Wicca is a religion doesn't mean it isn't. People like him are the reason why so many people are leaving Christianity for more open minded faiths. Pastor Johnston and people like him make Christianity look foolish and ignorant. All religions are valid as long as no one is being hurt, and I can assure you all, no one is getting hurt in Wicca.( President Bush should be ashamed of himself too, especially because as a world leader he should be more enlightened. He is in no position to decide what is a religion and what isn't.) "

Zerlinda wrote on Apr 1, 2007 5:01 PM:

" For me, this all comes down to the fact that we all have our own views. The REAL issue as far as I can tell is that everyone wants to tell everyone else what opinion/belief is right and what opinion/belief is wrong. The problem lays in that there is a lack of tolerance, from all sides. Regardless of which faith or religion you follow, as long as it isnt harming anyone else, each individual should have the right to choose. This whole situation where there is name calling and mud throwing and snarling and biting at each other only adds fuel to the fire. Why cant we just grow up and realise that it is EVERYONE'S birth-right, to choose the way in which they connect to the deity for themselves. I believe that no-one has the right to tell anyone else what they should or should not believe. "

Lowell wrote on Mar 29, 2007 11:36 PM:

" Anita, I wonder if you have even read the Constitution, much less understand it, considering your utterly false remark about it mentioning the "Christian church". Your Jeremiah Johnston's opinion has no place in this debate - it has nothing to do with any member of his faith, which is no more legitimate nor true than that of the Stewarts. And there are those of us who view your Jesus as a load of crap. To the point - if no pentacle is allowed, no cross should be either. "

Rose wrote on Mar 25, 2007 9:51 PM:

" I was raised luthren but changed to wiccan soon after I turned 13 alot of people will disreagard a 16 year old's opinion but I have researched every religion I can think of and I can not stand those people but I understand them. My mom is wiccan and my dad very strict christian so I have both veiws christians cannot and will not recogignize wiccanism or any pagan religon because it threatens and scares them to no end let alone disgusts most of them because they were mislead their entire life just as most christians were, like me. So on this subject it was completely and utterly stupid to ask a christian their opinion, because they don't understand let alone want too. That is all and I ask the Goddess to bless us in our troubled times and help us through our persecusion and descrimination. Blessed Be. "

Johanna wrote on Mar 24, 2007 11:30 AM:

" Anita dear, sorry to burst your bubble but there is no church mentioned in the Constitution at all. Perhaps you have a different Constitution? "

Post One wrote on Mar 24, 2007 1:00 AM:

" Anita, you're a moron, an imbecile and an insult to anyone who is educated. I find it particularly funny how you mention that you are “highly educated”. If this is so, how come you don’t know that the vigorously active founding fathers were Deists, in fact Benjamin Franklin hated Christianity. I hate to rant, but I am so tired of other people telling me that Paganism isn’t a valid choice all while they will continue to lie and cheat others, throw trash out the car window, drive in an aggressive manner forgetting all courtesy and kindness. So to leave you with one last thought in this disjointed ramble, here’s a Bad Religion song called Faith Alone. Heard a sermon from a creaky pulpit with no one in the nave I paid a visit to the synagogue and I left there feeling blame No one could tell me what to do, they had not the capacity to answer me "

Post two wrote on Mar 24, 2007 12:59 AM:

" What the world needs now is some answers to our problems We can't buy more time 'cause our tender isn't valid If your soul needs love you can get consoled by pity But it looks as though faith alone won't sustain us no more Watched the scientists throw up their hands conceding, "progress will resolve it all" Saw the manufacturers of earth's debris ignore another green peace call No one could tell me what to do, no one had the ability to answer me What the world needs now is some accountability We can't buy more time 'cause time won't accept our money If your soul needs love you can always have my pity But it looks as though faith alone won't sustain us no more... What the world needs now is some answers to our problems We can't buy more time 'cause our tender isn't valid What the world needs now is some accountability If your soul needs love you can get consoled by pity But faith alone won't sustain us anymore faith alone won't sustain us anymore "

Grey Wolfe wrote on Mar 23, 2007 10:55 PM:

" Anita, if you will check records from before this recent attempt to change history saying the founding fathers meant "Christianity" you will find that many were Unitarian. That isn't what you would call a Christian. In fact some Unitarian congregations now follow a Goddess. If the government decides which non-Christians can have a symbol on their markers, next they will decide which Christians can, and it may not be the form you follow. "

Johanna wrote on Mar 23, 2007 9:27 PM:

" I'm a patriotic American Pagan who loves her country for its freedoms and is confident that as a people we are on our way to fully realizing the promise of equality for all. "

Christopher Blackwell wrote on Mar 23, 2007 9:08 PM:

" The VA has no right to decide anything about a religion or what religious symbol a vet is buried under. That is the problem, the VA setting up rules that allow it to do such. That is unConstitutional. The religion is not the problem, the VA is the problem in its illegal decision to keep on disobeying the Constitution. "

Michael wrote on Mar 23, 2007 3:56 PM:

" I wonder when the intolerant members of the Christian community will be satisfied. No Pagans allowed in the military? When Paganism is declared illegal? When Pagans are forced out of the country? Excecuted? We Pagans are citizens of the U.S. of A and deserve better treatment from a religious group that preaches "God is love". As a Pagan, I have no problem with you believing however you want, all I ask is to be given the same courtesy. Maybe we as a country should look at who keeps starting the fights in this so-called culture war we hear so much about. The man died in service to his country, let him have his beliefs honored! And as far as this country being founded on Christian beliefs, let's not confuse the colonial rebels who threw off King George with the Pilgrims and Separatists of a century and a half earlier. Their rule here was over just after the Salem witch trials, where they proved themselves a bit too hasty. Most(though certainly not all) of our Founding Fathers were Deists and Freemasons and students of science, not Biblical literalists. "

Mark Pritchard wrote on Mar 23, 2007 1:49 PM:

" Given the fact that First Family Church is largely controlled by a single family with no acountability to anyone else, inclusing its own members, I find it very ironic that its pastor is accusing another faith of being a cult. I echo the comments by others that he should not have been asked to comment on this issue at all. A seminiary professor who specializes in comparitive religious studies would have been much better. This was lazy reporting. "

Kimberly Bitner wrote on Mar 23, 2007 11:30 AM:

" Anita; you may not agree with Wicca, but that's not the point. The point is that the government may not discriminate against anyone's freedom of religion. The Constitution does NOT say 'Freedom of Christianity'. It no longer matters what the founding fathers meant by religion, we are now a country of many religions, and our government must reflect that. The VA is engaging in religious discrimination, and this must stop. Remember, if they can discriminated against any one group, it's possible to discriminate against all. "The Prsident puts his hand on the Bible and swears to uphold the Constitution. He does not put his hand on the Constitution and swear to uphold the Bible." And our Constitution guarantees Freedom of Religion to us all. Not just those we may agree with. And for the record, though our family is Wiccan, we do indeed have a Bible in the house, and have all read it, including our kids as part of their homeschool education. We've studied many religions. It hasn't changed our faith. We are as entitled to our faith as you are to yours. "

Anita Chancey wrote on Mar 23, 2007 10:15 AM:

" I am offended by Ms. Anila's comments, as well as many who have written comments to this article. I am highly educated, have studied many belief systems, and finally realized there is only one true God, and you can have a relationship with Him only through his Son, Jesus Christ. And I personally know Jeremy Johnston, who is very well versed on the various belief systems that exist in our culture, and to call him ignorant is slanderous. It saddens me that this nation is slipping farther and farther from a right relationship with God under the concept of "separation of Church and state." The Church mentioned in the Constitution, folks, is the Christian Church - the Church that recognizes the inheritancy of the Word of God; not paganism, not Mormonism, not athesism, or any of the other "isms" that exist now. Open your hearts and truly study the Bible and your life will be changed forever. "

LaVada DelConte wrote on Mar 23, 2007 9:18 AM:

" In this so called country of freedoms, it seems that everyday we have to continuously fight just to have one precious freedom remain "FREE". Freedom of religion. Our country was built on bullies driving our ancestors here just to be able to practice freely. I have a son in the Army right now in Iraq and I would fight to make sure he had his faith symbol, and I know that as a SSG he would fight just as hard to make sure that mine as a pagan would be there. Recently the federal courts have considered paganism to be within the constitutional mandates of what a "proper" and legal religion is and wiccans are also practicing within their constitutional rights. So, last I knew, our country was supposed the be a melting pot of equality and in my mind that my "dears" includes all religions. "

Sherry Johnson wrote on Mar 23, 2007 4:29 AM:

" In reference to Rev.Beth Fields comment about this going against the Constitution-this country hasn't used the Constitution for much since the current administration took office.It's appalling that any human being can fight and die for thier country,only to be denied that one final show of respect they deserve-to have thier symbol of faith on thier headstone.Sometimes it's hard to believe this is 2007. "

Donald Kirby wrote on Mar 22, 2007 11:44 PM:

" This is blatant discrimination. I am organozing a campain in my state to write our congressional reps amd senators to fix this problem. It is pure bias and hate. "

Pat wrote on Mar 22, 2007 8:27 PM:

" I’ve served in the military, been through wars. I can’t count how many times I’ve heard “prayer call” out of a Minaret at 4am and was told ALL Americans have to be tolerant of different religions. I wonder why we can be tolerant of other religions overseas, and NOT BE tolerant on our own soil. After all, we do have the constitution in this United States. But, I guess those who have fought and served don’t have the broad based rights as do the majority. Case in point the soldier who died in Afghanistan. He was a Wiccan, and had been for many years. The V.A. refuses to put the symbol that represents his belief system on his grave marker. The V.A. has approved the symbol for many religions, to include atheism. When I was serving, I had “Wicca” imprinted on my dog/ID tags. It is a federally recognized religion. The military recognized it, however the V.A. won’t. What a slap in the face for the Constitution itself. So what rights do pagan veterans or dead pagans have under the constitution "

Bill Baldwin wrote on Mar 22, 2007 7:39 PM:

" The idea of the Constitution is that if all religion/ideas are presented on equal footing, then people will choose the better ideas/religions. Therefore, the admission by “Christian” fundamentalist that Wicca should not be allowed is an admission on their part that Wicca is a better religion, and therefore need be feared. "

The Rev. Jasper Sparrowhawk wrote on Mar 22, 2007 4:05 PM:

" I agree with the Rev. Beth Field. No government entity should be allow to approve or disapprove any religious symbol. The VA has overstepped its boundaries. In fact the constitution clearly states that no government entity may validate or invalidate a religion. So, why are these jerks at the VA being allowed to do so? It's flat out discrimination, and we as Americans need to put a stop to it, RIGHT NOW!!! Blessed Be! )O( "

Dorothy Garman wrote on Mar 22, 2007 3:16 PM:

" I am concerned that while a government agency is "revising" their rules, they can approve 7 or more grave symbols (some in less than a year!); but stall for more than 9 years over ONE! Freedom is what our soldiers are dying for, it seems disrespectful to not honor them. "

Dorothy Garman wrote on Mar 22, 2007 3:13 PM:

" I am concerned that while a government agency is "revising" their rules, they can approve 7 or more grave symbols (some in less than a year!); but stall for more than 9 years over ONE! Freedom is what our soldiers are dying for, it seems disrespectful to not honor them. "

Ariel wrote on Mar 22, 2007 2:58 PM:

" Freedom of religion means just that! Why would we, as a country, ask anyone to fight for another person's freedom while denying that soldier or Marine theirs is mindboggling. It is all about respect and this government and apparently Pastor Johnson does not have any respect for someone who thinks differently. "

Marilyn wrote on Mar 22, 2007 2:29 PM:

" Jesus’ Attitude Toward the State When Jesus Christ was on earth, he set higher standards for his followers, and he refused all involvement in political or military matters. After Jesus had miraculously fed several thousand people with a few loaves of bread and two small fish, Jewish men wanted to seize him and make him a political king. But Jesus avoided them by quickly withdrawing to the mountains. (John 6:5-15) Regarding this incident, The New International Commentary on the New Testament states: “There were fierce nationalistic longings among the Jews of that period, and doubtless many of those who saw the miracle felt that here was a divinely accredited leader, who was just the one to lead them against the Romans. So they set themselves to make him king.” It adds that Jesus “decisively rejected” this offer of political leadership. Christ gave no support to any Jewish insurrection against Roman domination.—Luke 21:20-24. John 18:36 “Jesus answered:”My kingdom is no part of this world. If my kingdom were part of this world, my attendants would have fought.” "

A reader wrote on Mar 22, 2007 2:26 PM:

" Freedom of religion means all religions. Regardless of whether or not you approve of Wicca, if the government can discriminate against Wicca now, they could discriminate against your religion later. Those who died serving our country deserve to have the symbol of their belief on their gravestones, no matter what that symbol is. It's only fair. The govenrment has no business determining what is or is not a religion. "

John Clary wrote on Mar 22, 2007 1:37 PM:

" Why did you ask a leader of a fundamentalist Christian church for a comment on the situation? This is a matter between the Wiccans and the government. I can give you contacts for Pagan churches in the KC area. Perhaps you would like to contct them for comments on dissension in mainstream Christian denominations, or the ongoing problem the Catholic church is haveing with sexually abusive priests? It would make as much sense as asking a Christian what they think about Pagan issues. "

Roberta Stewart wrote on Mar 22, 2007 12:20 PM:

" This discrimination needs to stop as a Wiccan Widow who fought long and hard, my grieving has just begun, The pain of losing my husband and being denied religious freedom will haunt me and my family the rest of our lives. I continue to work this quest so no more widows will have to go through this horrible nightmare of not being recognized. Please get involved and stop the Govt. from taking our rights away. "

Kimberly Bitner wrote on Mar 22, 2007 11:54 AM:

" Why would you include a quote from someone on a subject he knows nothing about? The Christian pastor quoted is not knowledgeable about Wicca, so he does not deserve to be given the space to denigrate anyone's religion. He shouldn't even have been given the chance to comment. Is this fair, unbiased reporting? I don't think so. "

Kelledia wrote on Mar 22, 2007 11:27 AM:

" As a former Catholic nun, a Wiccan since 1992 and now studying Druidry, I have seen both sides of this issue. A mature and open-mind can be a difficult thing to find, even in these times we consider progressive. It's amazing to think that so many symbols of other faiths are allowed, yet the pentagram - a time-honored symbol of spirit in action , is rejected , due to the fears of uneducated or even willfully ignorant people. May the light of reason bless us all. "

Meiri wrote on Mar 22, 2007 9:34 AM:

" The VA says they can't approve new symbols during the rule revision process, then goes on to approve several during that same process. I have also read that the VA states that there must be A central organization for any belief symbol to be approved. Tell me, what ONE organization speaks for all humanists or all athiests? Someone's lying, many times over, but then that's nothing new since 2000, is it? "

Pagan USAF SSgt. wrote on Mar 22, 2007 9:29 AM:

" I am a Pagan USAF SSgt. I have been to the Mid East 3 times now. Knowing that each time if I were to die my wife would have to fight for my right to have my symbol of faith upon my head stone. the whole thing is not right. We live,fight and sometimes die for the freedoms of others. It's time that me and my Pagan Military family get ours! "

Rev Beth Field wrote on Mar 22, 2007 7:45 AM:

" The VA should not be in the position of "approving" or not ANY religious symbol. Since when does the government get to decide what is and what is not a legitimate religion? This goes against the Constitution of the United States and the priniiples this country was founded upon. All regligious leaders should be united in this fight, because YOUR religion could be the next one to be discriminated against or unfairly judged. This is not a matter of agreeing or disagreeing with the beliefs of any person, but a matter of upholding their rights to practice those beliefs without discrimination. Beware - this is a slippery slope that can only lead to the erosion of more of our rights as Americans. "


(optional)
Current Word Count: